Thursday, May 14, 2020

If there’s any such thing as an enjoyable dip…

On 14 May 1997 I got an early morning call from Paul C – ‘Veery on Lundy’! This was disastrous news for me – I had enough time to make that morning’s sailing on the Oldenburg, but I knew I’d already pushed my luck a little too far over recent months in terms of taking time off work at short notice. I could have taken a sickie, but that wasn’t my style. Besides, my boss of the time (who, fair play, had been more than reasonable, most of the time) had once said that if she ever caught me taking a sickie for a bird all privileges would cease immediately and all requests for leave would have to be 24 hours in advance, in writing. So I would have to eat it this time and hope the bird stuck. That Paul and a few others managed to get on and see the bird (and his story of that day is an entertaining tale in itself) didn’t help. Nor did the prospect of the first clear night in a couple of weeks.

The birders assembling at Ilfracombe the next morning did so with a sense of foreboding, and we had our answer early, before we boarded the boat – no sign, despite searching. Still, we’d bought the tickets and there was always a chance that it was there but hiding – it had been elusive the previous day, after all. So we got on the Oldenburg (once dubbed, unforgettably, by a Devon birder I know, the ‘Old and buggered’) and off we went.

But the news continued to be negative, so we were pretty sure by the time we arrived at Lundy that it had gone. That was back in the days when the quay was not big enough for the Oldenburg to dock, so you had to climb off it into a tender to get on the island, and then there was the killer walk up the hill (that, of course, hasn’t changed). After mooching around the Millcombe Valley for a while, just to formalise the dip, we decided to go for a walk around the island. And that’s when the day and the mood made a change for the better.

With both the day twitchers and the few birders staying on the island spreading out, news came in of various finds, and I had a high old time that afternoon, twitching from bird to bird, in glorious sunshine. A very smart Woodchat Shrike up near Pondsbury was followed by a possibly even smarter male Red-backed Shrike near the western end of Quarter Wall, both giving great views. Then it was a short hike down into St John’s Valley where a Golden Oriole gave itself up after a little bit of a wait (a Devon tick, and still the only one I’ve ever seen in the county), and a Turtle Dove showed well there too. Add in a bunch of commoner migrants, and a couple of Puffins among the seabirds off the return crossing, and we almost managed to forget we were dipping an American mega-vagrant.

It took me another five years to see a Veery in Britain (a saga that involves a couple of stories worth recounting on another day), and I had no way of knowing on that day whether those opportunities would ever arise. But, while missing it inevitably cast a long shadow, the quality of the birds we did see made for a great day out otherwise. If there’s any such thing as an enjoyable dip, this one has to be right up there.

Wednesday, May 13, 2020

A long-awaited Somerset tick

Red-footed Falcons have become more regular in Somerset in the last decade or so, but they used to be very rare birds indeed in the county. After only a handful of previous records, at least 11 turned up in the massive 1992 influx, but I was new to the county then and didn’t have my own car, so missed them all (though on an East Anglian trip with Alastair Stevenson that June I ticked Redfoot near Swanton Novers in Norfolk and found my own near Lakenheath two days later).

Spool on 16 years then, to 2008, before the next chance came to add the species to my Somerset list. On 13 May a female was found over Shapwick Heath – I dived out  of work at 4 pm with Alastair and Stuart Holdsworth and headed straight up there. It was very mobile though, and the weather was turning – overcast and cool. After dashing out on Shapwick only to find it had drifted off south, we headed back to the car park and drove along the minor road along the south side of the reserve, through Buscott, in the hope of picking it up. But no joy. A certain amount of despondency set in, and there was talk of jacking it in, but I wasn’t prepared to give up just yet. But what best to do?

In the end we drove back to Ashcott Corner and walked out on to Shapwick again, much more in hope than expectation. We got as far as Noah’s Lake and had been scanning around for a while when suddenly I picked it up sat in one of the spindly dead trees to the north of the drain – oh, yesss! Where had that reappeared from? I got the news out and birders spread out over the site quickly gathered. It was a bit of a surprise to see a car coming towards us along the track from the Ashcott Corner end (the gates either end are locked and only reserve staff and a few regular volunteers have the combination), and even more of a surprise to see that in the front passenger seat was TV’s Simon King. Not that it had anything to do with the great man himself, but the car then very nearly ran over my foot!

Some enterprising soul had gone round through the wood to the Meare Heath hide and discovered that the bird was showing better from there, so we trogged round and joined them. Still scope views only, but very welcome indeed. It was now about 7.30 pm, though, so we decided to head home, very happy.

I’ve seen at least another four Redfoots in Somerset since, including the incredibly showy immature female not far from home at Isle Brewers in 2018, but gripping it back that evening, when it seemed so likely we would dip, was a special moment.

Tuesday, May 12, 2020

The Sprosser and the butterfly

I had ticked Thrush Nightingale at Dungeness in early May 1994, but though I saw it and heard it singing, the views were not as good as I would have liked. So, when one trapped at Landguard Obs in Suffolk in late August 1995 showed signs not only of putting in an extended stay but also of being abnormally showy, James McGill and I teamed up with Bill Urwin to make a play for it.

We arrived at Landguard before dawn on Sunday 3 September and positioned ourselves in front of the famous Icky Ridge, the bird’s favoured haunt, at first light. The usual anxious dawn wait, but thankfully not for long – Bill noticed a movement at the base of the ridge, then suddenly the Sprosser hopped out into the open. Fantastic views! We watched it for a long time, knowing we might never have a chance of such views of Thrush Nightingale again (and it hasn’t happened yet, 25 years later). But eventually we wandered away to have a look around and give thought to what else to do with the rest of the day.

News of a Greenish Warbler in Norfolk made up our minds. With Bill driving we were in Cromer in what seemed like no time, and joined a small crowd in the site of the old zoo. In what was now glorious warm sunshine, the Greenish was showing well and singing away – a new and interesting experience for me. Our next target was a Barred Warbler at Gramborough Hill near Salthouse, and again we were blessed and it did not take long after arrival to get good views. A nice bonus – not exactly brightly coloured, and no big deal for birders living on the east coast, but they’re much rarer in the southwest and I’d seen very few up to then.

What to do next? Well, another Greenish Warbler had been found in Wells Woods, so we headed to Holkham to look for it – why not? We hadn’t been there long though, and hadn’t seen the bird, when another pager message came through – Camberwell Beauty, in Norfolk! A rare and beautiful butterfly, and difficult to twitch, it was a big need for all of us, and one appeared to be hanging around in Hopton, near Great Yarmouth. We left immediately.

It’s probably best if I draw a veil over Bill’s driving on that leg, especially on the Norwich bypass – it was, erm, committed (though as it was Bill I always felt safe, strangely – well mostly, anyway). But he got us to Hopton Garden Centre in one piece and in double-quick time. On a sunny Sunday afternoon the garden centre was understandably busy anyway, and several other birders were already there too. The Camberwell Beauty had been favouring a buddleia just outside one of the large sheds full of plants and potential buyers, but had gone missing not long before we got there. Over the course of the next hour or so the bemused punters were treated to the sight of a bunch of nerds with bins scurrying around as the butterfly toured the site, being seen briefly before moving on. But at last it returned to its favoured buddleia and stayed there long enough for everyone, including us, to catch up with it. And what a wondrous, gorgeous thing it was! We attracted a crowd ourselves, watching the watchers, and were able to point it out to them and explain why it was so special. A fantastic experience, and very funny too.

After a while the Camberwell Beauty went off on a flyabout again, and as it was mid-afternoon we decided to start heading back towards the southwest. But we had one last stop to make on the way. A few days before, an adult Long-tailed Skua had turned up at Farmoor Reservoir in Oxfordshire and, perhaps even more surprisingly, it had stuck around. So we dropped in, and were so glad we did – not only was it an astonishingly beautiful bird, but so confiding too – the views were simply mind-blowing! It was a stunning end to a brilliant day.

Monday, May 11, 2020

Southeast year listing day trip, 1996

In 1996 I did a big year list, I mean a properly big one – 354 BOU on current taxonomy – which puts me in a fairly exclusive club (though there were three or four birders who finished with bigger totals that year alone, so I probably don’t even make top 10 all-time). It’s a total I will never beat, nor am I likely to try – not sure I could cope with the endless night drives these days, and it would be so much more expensive to do now. Not to mention the ridiculous carbon footprint it would leave.

But anyway, for anyone who has not done a big year list, here is a tale of a single day that spring that gives you an idea of what it’s like. And remember, this is one of the good days, when everything went well…

I had spent the working week planning that weekend’s targets and so had my route for Saturday 11 May worked out, attempting to mop up a list of target species across the southeast of England. An early start saw me cover the 120 miles or so up to the M25 before 9 am, and then out on to Staines Moor, where a dazzling female Red-necked Phalarope was still on the little pool it had been favouring for a few days. Great views of a great bird. But little time to linger, as the next target was two Night Herons found the day before at Lade Gravel Pits near Dungeness, another couple of hours’ drive away. Risky, for a couple of reasons: firstly, it was not a site I’d been to, despite various visits to Dunge, so it took a little time to find the way in. Also, the middle of the day is hardly the best time to be looking for Night Herons, of course, but in the end it didn’t take long to get decent views as they were roosting more or less in the open in a willow. Bonus!

Two targets down, two to go, and now time to start working my way back west. The next site was on the South Downs near Rottingdean. Not that far away, comparatively – only 60 or so miles from Dunge – but it was a snaggly drive along the south coast and took quite a while. And then there was a fair walk to do once there. But it was so worth it – good scope views of a trip of five Dotterel, including a couple of very smart females. Another year tick in the bag! As a bonus, alongside them, not a year tick but putting even the best of the Dotterel in the shade, was an absolutely stunning summer plumaged Golden Plover – the best looking one I’ve ever seen.

After the slog back off the downs and another hour’s driving, it was late afternoon before I arrived at Sidlesham Ferry Pool for my final target of the day, which also duly fell quickly – if only all days were like this one – a lovely Temminck’s Stint. Nowhere near as colourful as the other target waders seen on the day, but a dapper little thing all the same. And a real bonus here, as alongside it was a  Little Stint – another year tick! OK, one I was sure to get at some point, but very nice to bump into a pretty spring adult. It was early evening by now, but as my luck was in I decided to push it and nip the short distance down to Selsey Bill for a quick seawatch, in the hope of a Pom or two. No joy with that, but I could hardly complain.

I arrived home some 14 hours after leaving it that morning, having spent about 9 of those driving, solo, and with 450 more miles on the car. Utter madness, I know, but it had been a cracking day.

Sunday, May 10, 2020

Citril Finch, Norfolk

The forecast for Sunday 10 May 2015 looked good for migrants on Portland, so I headed down there early. No big fall, but there were certainly birds about, so after better views than the day before of the Tawny Pipit in the Crown Estate Field opposite the Obs, I headed up into Top Fields. Reaching the ‘Oriole Bushes’, I found a very smart hepatic morph female Cuckoo – a rare beast in itself, and showing well. I phoned it in to the Obs, and a few other birders came up to see it. Keeping an eye on it, I neglected to check my pager. Then another Portland regular asked me ‘So, are you off to Norfolk then?’ ‘Why, what’s there?’ ‘Citril Finch, just broken.’ Oh sh*t! For one reason and another I hadn’t been able to make it to the Fair Isle bird in 2008 – now I had a very unexpected chance to retrieve!

I legged it back down to the Obs and quickly prepared to leave, being waved off around 10 am by a small band of amused Obs regulars, one comment of ‘You’ll never make it’ ringing in my ears. Plenty of daylight left, just watch me try!

There’s little to tell about most of the drive up to Norfolk, apart from the usual stressed-out twitcher stuff – checking for updates, swearing at other drivers safe in the knowledge they couldn’t hear me, that kind of thing. Heading towards the coast from Fakenham I got passed by a red Skoda going like a bat out of hell – ‘birder’, I thought. Turns out it was LGRE – fair enough, he will know Norfolk roads better than I do – but I still arrived at Lady Ann’s Drive at Holkham only a minute or two behind him. The Citril Finch was showing at the west end of Holkham Pines as I arrived, but it was still a long enough walk to get out there – about 1½ miles (so too far to run, certainly for me). The positive updates from birders heading back helped, but still … like most birders I know, I have missed birds before by mere seconds.

About 40 minutes after leaving the car park, I arrived at the dell at the west end of the pines and, glory be, the Citril Finch was still present. Not on view immediately, but after only a couple of minutes or so, the stress of the drive and the walk turned to relief and then joy. I really, really, really didn’t expect to get that one back so quickly, if at all. And it was a smart little bird. It was also being obliging, showing well most of the time, and the views I had of this one were better than my only previous Citril Finches in the Pyrenees some 12 years before.

After about an hour or so of good views and chatting with various birders I knew there, and with afternoon turning to evening, I started the long slog back. Another bonus was great views of a trip of 20 Dotterels at Choseley Drying Barns, including some very smart females. Then it was the long drive home, arriving just before midnight.

My relaxation was short-lived. The Citril Finch only showed briefly very early next morning before disappearing for good, but then that afternoon a Moltoni’s Warbler was found on Blakeney Point, too late for me to drive back to Norfolk and get it. Paul and I dipped horribly the day after – the walk out and back nearly wiped us out. Still, I got Moltoni’s back, also on Blakeney Point, only three years later. It might be a much longer wait for another Citril Finch!



Saturday, May 9, 2020

Dalmatian Pelican

I suppose I wasn’t alone in not reacting too much when I saw Paul Freestone's news of a flyover ‘White Pelican’ at Gwithian in Cornwall on the evening of 7 May 2016. After all, we’ve been there many times before with White Pelican, and all have either been known escapes or the chances of them being escapees have been deemed too high by the powers that be for them to make the grade.

Things changed dramatically over the next couple of days as it was confirmed as having been a Dalmatian Pelican, and then on the morning of Monday 9th it was seen again near Land’s End. Twitch on! I couldn’t get down there till mid-afternoon, though, by which time it was proving itself to be very mobile, not staying in any one spot for long. Plenty of birders connected when it stood in a field just north of Sennen for nearly an hour, and I was getting regular updates from Cliff Smith, already on site, but it had disappeared again by the time I arrived.

A frustrating couple of hours followed, as it was seen again a couple of times briefly, including sat on Trevorian Pool for a short while. Dodgy mobile reception was not helping, as it was often difficult for those who bumped into it to pass on news quickly. Afternoon turned into evening, it was cool and misty, and I faced the prospect of dipping and having to either stop over or come back the next day.

The remaining birders looking were by now a bit spread out. I knew Alan Lewis and a few others had headed to Polgigga to look there, so I started heading that way, but decided to stop opposite the entrance to Skewjack Farm for a think. It seemed like a decent vantage point in itself, and the gulls on the farm outbuildings would surely let me know if anything the size of a pelican was flying around. So I stayed there and scanned, though without feeling much hope.

Suddenly, the gulls off to the northwest went up – I scanned through them and found a very large bird flying east. It was the pelican! Even better, it turned and starting heading towards me. Stunned, I watched as it circled over Skewjack and then came down, landing in a field very close by. It was out of sight at first, but a quick shift down the road about 50 yards and I could see it from the road, stood in the field!

Dalmatian Pelican over Skewjack Farm (Photo: © Alan Lewis)
Another advantage of my viewpoint was actually having some mobile signal, so I could spread the news. A small crowd largely made up of some of Britain’s keenest listers quickly built up, and all got fantastic views of the bird. I confess I was feeling quite pleased with myself – a world away from twenty minutes earlier.

The pelican stayed in that field for maybe 30 minutes or so, but true to form it suddenly decided to move elsewhere. In doing so, it flew almost directly overhead (which is when Alan got his stunning pic) – awesome to see such a massive bird at such close range!

I left for home, very happy. I still thought its chances of being accepted were no more than 50:50, at best, but it was in the bag, just in case. And yes, when it eventually moved up to the Taw Estuary in the autumn, I made sure I saw it there too, ready to go on my Devon list if it was accepted. Which of course duly, though still a little surprisingly, happened a couple of years later – bonus!

Friday, May 8, 2020

The Booted Eagle saga part II


Earlier in this series of birding tales, I covered the extraordinary weekend in April 1999 that included finally seeing the Booted Eagle at Lady’s Island Lake, Wexford, at the third attempt (having dipped once in Dublin in March and previously in Wexford that month).

But of course, the Booted Eagle story doesn’t end there. It was claimed a number of times that April, in various locations including in Waterford and Down, prompting the editors of Birding World to print that Ireland ‘was awash with Booted Eagle sightings’. It would be unkind to suggest that this dismissive attitude was because they hadn’t seen it yet, and scepticism about some of the sightings was rife, but as one of the sightings was ours and they certainly knew who had seen it that day, safe to say some of us were not that impressed with them at the time. Be that as it may, it headed north and later turned up on Rathlin Island (where the BW eds did catch up with it), then went missing.

After a bit of a gap, punctuated only by a brief sighting in Kent, suddenly, in late October, it was in Cornwall! OK, so we’d seen it in Ireland so it was happily pencilled in on British and Irish List (pending acceptance, of which more later), but now it was also a first for Britain. (To pre-empt any arguments, Rathlin Island is in the UK, but Northern Ireland is not part of Britain for bird recording purposes. Nor is the Isle of Man, but that’s another story.)

Paul and James dashed down to Drift Reservoir and saw it. I was only an hour or so behind them, but dipped. There was a bit of keystone cops incident later where several carloads of birders all dashed down a country lane and there were plenty of happy ‘oohs’ and ‘aahs’ while watching a raptor sat in a field, but it was very obviously a Buzzard, so I left them to it.

A few days later, I went down to look again, and took old friends Stuart Holdsworth and Alastair Stevenson with me this time. The Booted Eagle was still around, but it was being a sod again, drifting around the Toe, but mostly around St Buryan. Touring the area in hope, we had just passed the turning for Lamorna and were approaching the Merry Maidens stone circle when the bloody thing flew low across the road directly in front of us! I recognised it instantly and screeched to a halt in a gateway so the boys could leap out and get a good view as it flew low north down the field, mobbed by corvids. Result!

It stayed in Cornwall for most of November, then disappeared. After a few months of radio silence on it, I think we all assumed it had gone. Then, in March 2000, I was in Poole looking for a Green-winged Teal when the pager beeped once more. The first time I think I had ever seen Mega and Somerset in the same message – the Booted Eagle was over Shapwick Heath, now! Panic! I made it back to the Levels as soon as I could, abandoned the car in the car park at Ashcott Corner, and ran. The first birders I met said ‘Yes, it’s still here’ – great! A short time later I was getting great views of it circling over Meare Heath – closer views than in Ireland, and a lot longer views than in Cornwall. All that running around after it, and I get my best views on the Avalon Marshes – what are the odds? A few days later it had moved to Chew Valley Lake and I saw it there too, just for the hell of it.

But after all that – twitching it seven times, seeing it four times, in four different counties across two countries – I still can’t tick it. It has never been accepted either side of the water. A joint press release by BOURC, IRBC, and NIBARC (representing Northern Ireland) says that they weren’t prepared to accept it for a number of reasons, including feather wear, the time of year it was originally found, and concerns about their ability to make long sea crossings. (See full text here: http://www.irbc.ie/announcements/announce3.php.) Rumours abounded at the time that political sensitivities meant that the BOURC of the time didn’t want to be seen to disagree with IRBC about a bird which turned up in Ireland first, and so were not prepared to accept the record into Category A for that reason also. Whatever the truth of it, it is frustrating, but while I don’t always agree with records committee decisions, I abide by them, for good or ill – I’ve gained often enough out of them. The committees may change their minds over time, especially if another should turn up. Twitching is a long game anyway – I can wait.